This article is a contribution from our content partner, Bracket
There was a time when valuing FX contracts was easy for most mid-sized corporates: a quick call to your bank, a spreadsheet entry, job done. But that era’s gone – and today, independence matters more than ever.
For a growing number of finance leaders, FX valuations are becoming one of the hardest areas to defend at audit – not because the numbers are necessarily wrong (or hopefully not!), but because the process behind them no longer holds up.
Alongside initiatives like the FX Global Code, auditors are raising the bar. Simply pointing to a hedging policy and saying “we followed it” won’t wash anymore. Not if you want to qualify for hedge accounting treatment.
Instead, audit teams want to see how trades were priced, valuations were confirmed, and execution decisions were justified – ideally with documentation and independent validation.
So, where is it going wrong?
When ‘good enough’ no longer cuts it
Valuations (the fair value of your forwards, options, swaps, or large spot positions etc.) directly impact your P&L, balance sheet, and hedge accounting. Conceptually it sounds simple: what is this contract worth today? But in practice, it’s rarely that clear.
Many corporates still rely on valuations from the same banks that sold them the trade. Sure, that’s convenient. But these marks typically lack transparency and any form of external validation.
That’s becoming an audit red flag – especially for structured trades, where the pricing model can’t easily be explained or tested. Increasingly, auditors want to see valuation processes that are:
- Transparent – with clearly documented methodologies (e.g. mark-to-market) based on observable data.
- Independent – not reliant solely on information from the counterparty who executed the trade, or unverified spreadsheets.
- Reproducible – someone outside treasury should be able to follow and recalculate them.
- Compliant – aligned with IFRS 9 for hedge accounting, with clear documentation of how hedging instruments and exposures are linked.
Expectations for more frequent FX valuation checks are also rising – with quarterly marks becoming the bare minimum[1].
[1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S027842542400019X
Not a burden but an opportunity
| Do I need an independent valuation for every FX trade or hedge? | No. Start with what’s material – large exposures, complex instruments, or anything with a visible impact on your numbers. Spot-checking can be sufficient to uncover trends. |
| Do we need to benchmark daily? | Not unless you want to! Daily valuations may become standard for highly structured portfolios, but many corporates begin with monthly or quarterly checks, focusing on transparency and reproducibility. |
| Will this help with hedge accounting? | Yes. Independent valuations provide stronger, more auditable evidence for effectiveness testing – a key requirement under IFRS 9. This can help prevent restatements and support more stable reporting. |
| How do we explain this to the board or audit committee? | Many audit committees are already asking, “How do we know this number is fair?” Being able to say, “we independently benchmark our largest exposures and document the methodology” is often enough to inspire confidence. |
| Where should we start? | Pick one recent FX trade – preferably a larger forward – and run an independent benchmark against it. Comparing that result with what was booked is a great first step. |
| How much time or budget does this take? | Far less than you might expect. Independent FX valuations can be layered onto existing processes – often without any system changes or significant cost. |
Need independent FX valuations – without the audit headache?
Bracket’s tools provide accurate, market-driven FX valuations across your portfolio with transparent methodologies and audit-ready reports, so you can:
- Benchmark or value spot and structured trades (historic or live)
- Get independent mark-to-market valuationsfor hedge accounting or audit support
- Identify execution issues and optimise across banks
- Start without any system changes or ongoing cost for pre-trade checks
Also Read
Join our Treasury Community
Treasury Mastermind is a community of professionals working in treasury management or those interested in learning more about various topics related to treasury management, including cash management, foreign exchange management, and payments. To register and connect with Treasury professionals, click [HERE] or fill out the form below to get more information.