Are Bigger Banks Better? A Corporate Treasurer’s Perspective

Introduction

In the world of corporate treasury, choosing the right banking partner is a crucial decision that can impact cash management, liquidity, and risk mitigation. Recent industry moves, such as UniCredit’s potential takeover of Commerzbank and BBVA’s multibillion-dollar bid for Spain’s Sabadell, highlight a trend toward consolidation in the banking sector. As banks grow larger, many corporate treasurers may ask: Are bigger banks truly better for Treasury operations?

This article will explore the benefits and potential drawbacks of larger banking institutions from a corporate treasury perspective. We’ll dive into how size affects service offerings, risk, and relationship management, and provide insight into whether treasurers should prioritize size in their banking decisions.

1. Bigger Banks: The Benefits

Global reach and connectivity

Larger banks typically offer a broader geographic footprint, which can be invaluable for multinational corporations. Treasurers managing complex, multi-currency operations benefit from a bank with a global network, simplifying cross-border transactions, foreign exchange, and cash pooling.

Broader Product Offering

Big banks tend to provide a wider range of services, from sophisticated derivatives for hedging currency and interest rate risks to advanced cash management systems. This breadth of products can meet more complex treasury needs under one roof, offering scalability as a business grows.

Stronger Balance Sheets

Large banks are often better capitalized, making them more stable and less vulnerable to financial shocks. This can reduce counterparty risk for corporate treasurers, especially during economic downturns or periods of financial market volatility.

2. The Drawbacks of Bigger Banks

Potential for Less Personalized Service

As banks grow larger, treasurers may experience more bureaucracy and less tailored customer service. Larger institutions may focus on their most profitable clients, leaving smaller corporations or mid-sized firms feeling overlooked.

Slower Decision-Making

Due to their size, large banks can be slower in responding to customer needs, particularly when it comes to customizing solutions or making decisions on credit facilities. Treasurers who need agility in their banking relationships may find this frustrating.

Higher Fees

Large banks often have more overhead costs, which can be passed on to their customers in the form of higher fees for services, from transaction costs to liquidity management solutions.

3. What Do Corporate Treasurers Need Most

The Balance Between Innovation and Service

Bigger banks often have the resources to invest in cutting-edge technology, such as artificial intelligence (AI) and blockchain, which can drive more efficient treasury operations. However, technology alone isn’t always the answer. Treasurers also need a banking partner that understands their business and offers a strategic partnership, regardless of size.

Risk Mitigation and Counterparty Exposure

For many treasurers, the stability of their banking partner is paramount. Larger banks, with their diversified portfolios, tend to offer more security. However, diversifying across smaller, specialized banks can also spread counterparty risk.

Conclusion: Bigger Isn’t Always Better—But It Can Be

As corporate treasurers evaluate their banking relationships, the size of the institution should not be the sole determining factor. While bigger banks bring advantages in terms of reach, product breadth, and stability, smaller or mid-sized banks can often offer more personalized service and flexibility.

Ultimately, the key is to strike a balance between the treasury’s unique needs and what a bank, regardless of its size, can offer. Treasurers should focus on the quality of the relationship, the bank’s ability to support strategic initiatives, and its capability to deliver innovation and stability in a rapidly evolving financial landscape.

This framework considers both sides of the debate, allowing corporate treasurers to reflect on their own needs and the value bigger banks might or might not provide. Would you like to add any specific insights or examples from your experience?

Join our Treasury Community

Treasury Mastermind is a community of professionals working in treasury management or those interested in learning more about various topics related to treasury management, including cash management, foreign exchange management, and payments. To register and connect with Treasury professionals, click [HERE] or fill out the form below to get more information.